Tuesday, April 23, 2013

'She should be playing with dolls, it's shocking': Colombian girl, 10, gives birth to baby daughter


A 10-year-old Colombian girl has sparked outrage after becoming one of the world's youngest ever mothers by giving birth to a healthy daughter.
The girl, a member of an indigenous tribe called the Wayuu who are based in the La Guajira Peninsula in the north of the country, was 39 weeks pregnant when she underwent a Caesarean section. Most pregnancies are 38 weeks. 
It was the first time the pre-teen, from the town of Manaure, had visited a doctor in connection with her pregnancy.


She reportedly arrived at the hospital bleeding, in floods of tears and 'enormous' pain from the contractions.
Doctors decided to carry out the risky operation because of her age - and both mother and daughter, who weighed just 5lbs, are said to be 'doing well'.


Although Colombian police could prosecute the father for underage sex, the country's constitution guarantees the Wayuu a certain amount of autonomy. It allows the tribe to maintain its own sovereignty and certain cultural heritages, of which one is said to be the giving birth of children at an extremely young age. In any case the community has remained tight-lipped as to the identity of the father, with some Colombian newspaper speculating it is a 15-year-old boy. Others believe it is a 30-year-old man.




After her sister died, Tino was married off to her brother-in-law when she was 9 years old.


When Tino was 9, she spent her days tending to small animals in her pastorialist village in Ethiopia.
The child had never attended school, and was barely old enough to have a passing understanding of cultural traditions in her village. But that all changed after her much-older sister died in childbirth.
A few months after her sister's death, Tino noticed village elders visiting her him and having lengthy talks with her parents. She didn't pay much attention to the visitors; she was more interested in playing with the clay animal figures she molded with her friends. Soon, though, her parents told her to stop playing with mud. They forced her to stay inside and bought her a few nice items of clothing. Visitors came more frequently, bringing food and drinks with them.
After a while, Tino got up the courage to ask her mother what was happening. That's when Tino found out that she was getting married. Married? To whom?
Tino soon found out that she was to marry her dead sister's husband, a man 26 years her elder. As is common practice in her society, the young child inherited her sister's husband and newborn child.
Two years later, Tino doesn't talk much about her duties as a wife, but it's clear she cooks for the family and looks after the child.
Today, Tino also participates in CARE's Healthy Unions program, a project that promotes the human rights of girls and women by decreasing the harmful traditions of bride abduction, bride price and early marriage in Ethiopia. Through the project, Tino and her husband receive counseling and support – and Tino is enrolled in school for the first time in her life.

The evil child marriage is


The plight of two 12-year old girls, one described as Christian and the other as Muslim, has again highlighted the large-scale abuse of women’s rights in Pakistan caused by a single evil practice-child marriage.

When Asiya was recovered from the clutches of her husband in a village near Lahore she bore quite a few marks of brutality including broken bones. She had also been given electric shocks. The husband did not deny beating the girl or subjecting her to other forms of violence. He justified his bestiality on two grounds. First, the girl had run away from her husband’s house more than once and therefore she deserved to be whipped. Secondly, her father had condoned the girl’s thrashing, had washed his hands off her, and had allowed her master to do with her as he pleased.

Countless women, girls and adults both, have undergone the ordeal suffered by Asiya. She is fortunate that the police recognized their duty to rescue her from a house of terror because generally they do not interfere in cases of wife-bashing. There have been instances when the judiciary too has declined relief to a woman battered by her husband. Some time ago a 13-year-old girl, who had been mercilessly beaten by her much older husband, sought relief from the Lahore High Court. The court declined to intervene because it could not proceed against the girl’s legally wedded spouse.

Women who go to the police to complain of violence by their husbands are usually told to make up with their tormenters. Three reasons are given for this advice. First, it is argued that the husband has a right to apply physical force to compel the wife to obey him and that it is always wayward or rebellious women who invite punishment. Secondly, the complainant is warned that litigation takes long to bear fruit and that women generally do not have the resources to wait for justice. And, thirdly, the woman is told to take into consideration the tribulations she will face after losing her husband’s protection, especially when the doors of parental dwelling have already been closed on her.

The police view unfortunately does not conflict with the social attitude towards women that are victims of domestic violence. For several decades, especially since General Zia-ul-Haq decided to reverse women’s march towards freedom and equality with men, the Pakistani male has been allowed the right to use violence not only against his wife but also against any female member of the family. This privilege is now upheld by a larger proportion of the male population than was the case a few decades ago. Religion is used to convince women to accept getting clubbed by their husbands as a duty. Many of them see no wrong in getting roughed up by their husbands or other male members of family.

The part attributed to Asiya’s father in this story is quite common in Pakistan. Most families, especially economically weak ones, try to pack their daughters/wards off in marriage as early as they can. Every now and then the media picks up a story about a little girl being sold for a paltry amount. One has seen a declaratory deed duly written on a stamp paper by a professional petition writer whereby a man sold his daughter in marriage against a small payment. Sale of girls under the pretext of marriage is not confined to any particular faith or sect. People belonging to different religions have been guilty of buying and selling brides. The authorities know it, the politicians know it and so do the media persons. All of them seem to have surrendered to a most evil practice because they think nothing can be done about it. Asiya’s story will also be forgotten within a few weeks and the matter will disappear from the public radar till another Asiya’s story finds its way to the front pages.

In the second case the Lahore High Court ruled that a girl, who was below the marriage age, as prescribed in the Child Marriage Restraint Act, but had attained puberty, had a right to take a husband without the consent of her parents. The issue had arisen when the father of 12 and a half years old Zeenat lodged an FIR under the Zina Ordinance to the effect that she had been abducted by a neighbour and that they had been living together in sin. This story was denied by Zeenat, by now pregnant, and she firmly chose to stay with her husband.

There can be no argument against the court’s decision to save the girl’s marriage and the future of her child, and to frustrate her unreasonable father’s bid to join the crowd that has been abusing the provisions of the Zina Ordinance. However, by virtually striking down the minimum age for girls’ marriage the decision has raised two issues which need to be examined dispassionately.

First, the court followed a strict interpretation of the law which says that a girl can be given away in marriage on attaining the age of 16 or puberty, whichever is earlier. It also dealt a blow to the argument about the wali’s consent being essential for a woman’s marriage by declaring that a girl who is considered fit to marry also has the right to choose her life-partner. In the process the evil that child marriage is apparently got overlooked. The question now is whether courts should have nothing to do with social evils that come to their notice and which somehow enjoy legal sanction.

Countless examples can be given of references by the judiciary both before and after independence to the need for changing laws that conflict with basic rights or principles of natural justice. However, Pakistani courts are generally wary of taking exception to any provision of law that is defended on the grounds of belief. The difficulties the judiciary faces in questioning practices presented as religious injunctions cannot be ignored, but the reluctance to demand satisfaction on the authenticity of the religious argument involved cannot be appreciated. The least the judiciary can do is to call for an authoritative review of the legal formulation.

The second issue is whether Pakistan has decided to abandon the struggle our society has made for decades to abolish child marriage. It is worth recalling that one of the Quaid-e-Azam’s most notable contributions to law-making in the subcontinent was his success in 1929 in extending the scope of the Sarda Bill, whose mover had sought to create restrictions only on marriages of small Hindu girls, to Muslim girls as well. He was opposed by almost the entire body of Muslim clergy, except for Maulana Shibli Nomani. It was as a rejoinder to them that he had declared that he was answerable only to the voters in his constituency and not to clerics, and that if these voters were so backward as to disapprove of restraints on child marriage he would ask them to elect someone else in his place. In the course of his speech on the Bill he said that he did not pretend to be an alim or an authority on theology but that during the 30 years of his fairly active practice he had always understood that “marriage law had nothing to do with religion as such; that marriage was a contract according to Muhammadan Law, pure and simple.” He also asked “whether there is any text which makes it obligatory on Musalmans that they should get their daughters married before the age of 14,” and added, “there is no text.”

The defenders of child marriage often argue that girl-brides have the right to wriggle out of an unwanted marriage when they attain puberty and before the marriage is consummated. This protection had some meaning when small girl-brides stayed at parental homes for long periods after the marriage rites had been performed. There is no protection for a girl who is handed over to her husband at the age of ten or 12 and her husband does not wait for her to reach puberty before consummating a relationship his victim cannot even comprehend.

Quite often girls from poor families are given in marriage to rich old men and the parents rationalize such marriages by asserting that the girls will enjoy better life than they could ever hope for at parental homes. The argument is quite facetious because a well-fed slave is a slave nonetheless and promise of some comfort is no compensation to a minor girl’s sexual exploitation or the denial to her of possibilities of development into a useful member of society.
An important issue in this debate is the assumption that the girl’s attainment of puberty also means her mental maturity. After all, a woman is not merely a vehicle for sex and procreation. A girl who starts performing the functions of a wife at the age of ten or 12 is denied all possibilities of mental growth. She cannot understand the duties and rights of a wife, to say nothing of her responsibilities as a mother and as a member of society. That is why societies that allow child marriages are denounced for planning under-developed generations.

That the Pakistani society should be called upon to discuss in the 21st century the pros and cons of child marriage offers a measure of the social and intellectual regression that the nation has suffered. Nevertheless, the urgency of addressing the issue is manifest. Even if it is difficult to reconstruct religious thought, to borrow an essential phrase from Iqbal, the possibilities of protecting the rights, including the right to develop
ment, of girls married off at a tender age under the rule of puberty must be seriously explored.

India leading world’s child marriages: UN


Every second girl in India is married underage, the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) said on Friday in a fresh assessment of global child marriage patterns that paints a worrying picture of a practice widely banned but still rampant.
India has the largest number of child brides in the world, with 47% girls married under the legal age of 18, the UNFPA said, projecting that 140 mn child marriages may take place between 2011 and 2020, cutting across most developing nations.
On an average, that means 39,000 child marriages every day.
The shocking numbers came on International Women’s Day, at a time when India is debating strengthening laws on crimes against women.
One of the proposals under consideration is lowering the age of consent for sex from 18 to 16 years, irrespective of marriage.
“Child marriage is an appalling violation of human rights and robs girls of their education, health and long-term prospects,” Babatunde Osotimehin, UNFPA executive director said.
The UNFPA has also projected that of the 140 mn girls who will be married under 18 by 2020, 50 mn will be under the age of 15.
Niger (75%), Chad (68%), the Central African Republic (68%), Bangladesh (66%), Guinea (63%), Mozambique (56%), Mali (55%), Burkina Faso and South Sudan (52%) and Malawi (50%) are the top 10 nations with highest incidence of child marriages, according to the UNFPA.






Monday, April 22, 2013

Call to guide youths on higher studies —II

The Pakistan government does not see who is teaching which syllabus or their set of syllabus is the requirement of the country. Language is the major issue of Pakistani educational institutions as some are focused on the English language while others are teaching the language in Urdu accent. Pakistani students and educationists are unaware of global education demands while amendments in the required education system could be made by politicians. But it is also a fact those have knowledge of it are unable to contest and win elections. The next government should engage people who are aware of changing global educational requirements in education policymaking and make then ministers or advisers and also empower them to make decisions. 
Q: Are Pakistani youths capable of bringing the country out of crisis? 
A: Yes, Pakistani youths are competent and intelligent and aware of everything. Pakistani students, who went to the US, the UK and Australia, were hired there due to their capabilities and some are working at ministerial level and the Pakistani brain is playing a vital role in the growth of the western world. Why cannot we stop brain drain, bring Pakistanis back to the country who are working at top level abroad? Great importance is attached to education in the US and the UK and consultative committees of stakeholders are formed and governments give preferences to recommendations of the committees. The Higher Education Commission (HEC) of Pakistan was also established on the same pattern but its powers were limited as compared to US and UK educational institutions. Educational monitoring institutions of the US and the UK hold strict audit of their institutions and check students are satisfied with their education. The consultative committees interview students and if they are not satisfied with their university education, the committees stop universities from educating students. The committees also look into the available research material, libraries and reference sections of the universities, check research and theory materials and those lacking are closed. Students are also given representation in the committees while universities also provide opportunities to students to give their suggestions to review committees.
It is the responsibility of the Pakistani government to learn from the experiences of other countries and reform education in accordance with local requirements. In Pakistan, teachers or vice-principals are part of school committees but their responsibilities are limited to review daily expenses. School management committees are not empowered in Pakistan while the Directorate of Education Department has all powers. Whenever local level changes are required, everything moves to Lahore. There is a need to empower committees at local level but in Pakistan 90 per cent power is held by either politicians or education secretary. These are people who send their children abroad for education and never return due to poor standards as they cannot adjust with the Pakistani system. In other words, children of Pakistani politicians and bureaucrats have become part of the foreign education system and their elders are unaware of changes in the western education system. 
Q: Can education sector expenditure solve problems? 
A: Surely, advantages of the education sector equal other sectors as in the long run education sector expenditures will give more benefits than all other sectors. Education is a solution to all problems, ranging from law and order, energy crisis, health and other civic facilities, bad governance, corruption and others. Only that country will rule whose education system is better. In the past, the US and the UK provided better education systems and prioritised education to other sectors and became superpowers. Other evils of society will automatically eradicate with increase in education sector spending. Highly qualified persons can evolve better economic policies and bring the country out of poverty. Nobody knows how to end the energy crisis as irrelevant persons are appointed on technical positions. We can lay the foundation of revolutionary changes by appointing education sector experts as ministers, advisers or on other positions like heads of universities, syllabi authorities etc. The fate of Pakistan can be changed within two to six years by correcting the direction of the education sector. 
Q-Our teachers too use unfair means in examination?
A-We have certain so-called education experts whose researches are found to be exact copies of others. Some experts cut and paste through computers and produce fake research papers. How can they develop the country when they steal others’ researches? Breaking laws are their second nature. 
Q-What is the number of those who are getting genuine degrees?
A-According to a 2010-11 report, the enrolment for higher degrees was 868,000. The youths were getting education in different categories but their majority did not understand changes occurring in the world and their systems, nor they upgraded their personalities according to requirements of modern times. 
Q-Can franchise education system bring any improvement to education standard?
A number of franchises and experts of various education systems are busy marketing themselves in our country on a daily basis, promoting their own brands of education systems. But they do not understand international trends of changes or international marketing. Europe has kept a more vigilant eye on the needs of Pakistan and other countries than us. When Islamic banking began spreading in our country and State Bank evolved the rules and regulations, western universities started new degrees in the field. A British university awarded degrees in Islamic banking over eight years back when we could not even think of it. Our banks adjusted their old workers in Islamic banking by giving them little training without proper expertise or experience. Due to these deficiencies, the sector could neither make significant progress according to requirements, nor generate enough job opportunities. The biggest hurdle to progress in the sector is the shortage of expert manpower. Several departments of Islamic banking are not taught in Pakistan altogether. Our degrees lack internationalisation. We look away from changes at world level. Then our students who study abroad chose to settle there. In this way, western countries are making full advantage of internationalization. We can take advantage of ‘cross-border education’, that is, students can study with universities outside their countries through the internet. In this way, students of most backward countries can take degrees of top world class universities. One such degree is to study for some time in one’s own country and then go to a foreign country. But the standard of education should not be compromised in any condition. We need experts of sectors which face crisis. After a severe power crisis, we should promote education in this sector. Take services of experts in energy conservation. Poverty is a big problem and degrees are available in this sector. We have spent hundreds of billions of rupees in the last few years to eliminate poverty but results are poor because funds were probably not spent in the right direction due to lack of planning. We need experts in poverty alleviation so we should have started new degrees in this sector. In the health sector, first dengue struck and now measles is a big danger. Billions of rupees were spent to prepare vaccine and acquire experts to control the epidemics. When a new disease is spread in the west, the officials sector and education institutions begin research on it immediately. Pakistan needs new degrees for dengue prevention and cure. We could have sent 15 to 20 experts to foreign countries to learn their expertise and serve the country after coming back. If our experts continue to settle abroad we will not be able to control the situation inside the country. Politicians need to make policies in this regard. Our literacy rate is estimated at 50 to 55 percent but actually it is below 30 per cent. We have been giving too many privileges to a certain class and need to change the policy to divert the privileges to the deserving. 
Q: Your main focus remained degrees or standard?
A: For higher education, we focus on getting more degrees but the level of education should be given importance. Every university has its own method of entrance test, should not politicians think about it? In our country, every university has established its own method of entrance test and examination system which is different than the other university. A uniform policy at national level is the need of the hour because some institutes have an inclination toward certain class of society. The inclination needs to be removed. 
A well thought-out method of entrance test should be applied uniformly to all higher educational institutes. Due to poor policies, every school is holding an entrance test of its own. So the same entrance test should be conducted at O-level and A-levels. English school system and Madaris school system are producing different kinds of people in a same society. In some institutes, the trend of science learning does not exist which is alarming for students. The government should also send experts in schools for guidance of students. All institutes should have the same curriculum and English should be declared as a medium of learning at primary level which will surely leave an impact on the education sector at primary level. Trained teachers at primary level will enhance the learning of students who would do well at higher level. By adopting the same way of learning, unbalancing of our educational system would be decreased. That’s why we need good policymakers. 
Q: We have Boards at our school and colleges levels?
A: In higher educational institutes, principals do not enjoy power as they cannot recruit or transfer any staffer. Devolution of power is needed at lower level and for this purpose, a devolution policy should be made to facilitate students. A college principal can better understand problems of a student. Nowadays, a music teacher is teaching sports, on Physics seat, an English teacher is teaching and similarly, at the post of English, English teachers are teaching. The process is affecting the whole educational system. 
Q: Can we improve our education sector by sending experts to far-flung areas instead of opening new universities?
A: I have mentioned earlier the hard allowance which was related to it. Everywhere in the world, hard allowance is given to all those who work in tough circumstances. Army also gives that allowance to its personnel deployed at Siachen and other difficult points. Their deployment at those points is part of their training. We can also lay down the foundation of overcoming the backwardness of far-flung areas by sending our educational experts but to achieve that we have to award extra allowance to the teachers. People of backward areas should benefit from those well-trained experts. Extra expenditures will have to be borne if hundreds of students would come to Lahore and Karachi for higher learning due to lack of required institutes. We can help such students in higher learning at their doorsteps by giving experts extra pay. By establishing such a network, we can improve mental strength of students of Gilgit-Baltistan, DI Khan, Azad Jammu and Kashmir and Fata. 



Vani no way to fend feuds

Vani is a local custom of giving females mostly minors in marriage by an offending party to the males of the victim party as consideration of compromising offences. Agonizingly, in most of the cases the elderly ones are asked to marry Vani (minor) girls. Despite being criminalized under the Prevention of Anti-Women Practices Act, passed in 2011, the Vani cases are continuously making headlines in the national press. Earlier this week, a Jirga in Dera Bugti, Balochistan declared 13 girls Vani in a bid to settle a murder conflict between the Bagirani and Shahwani tribes of the area. Similarly, on October 4, two Vani cases were reported from separate localities of Mansehra. 
According to a report, as many as 341 cases of forced marriages have been reported in 27 districts in May 2012. The report further says that cases of forced marriages have decreased in Punjab and Sindh while a significant increase of 66 per cent was registered in Islamabad Capital Territory from where 24 cases were reported as compared to last year’s nine. Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan also observed an increase. Knowingly the Vani custom is illegal rather a serious crime in Pakistan and it can be avoided under the Islamic law of Deet yet the “elders in the society” practice it, ignoring the punishment under the law of the land.
Of late, the Supreme Courts of Pakistan has taken serious notice and action against the continuation of the practice. On Thursday hearing the suo motu notice of a Jirga, the Supreme Court of Pakistan ruled that the girls and the tribal elders involved in the Dera Bugti Vani incident be presented before it and the case be thoroughly investigated. 
The court also summoned Sarfaraz Bugti, a cousin of a local MPA Mir Tariq Masuri, who allegedly chaired the Jirga to appear before the court. Obviously, the law will take its course and the violators will not go unpunished—at least such is the resolve of the Chief Justice of Pakistan. 
The matter of serious concern is that the custom is outlawed and punishable with jail term up to seven years and a fine to the tune of Rs 0.5 million yet the influential people continue to practice these customs to settle their disputes, upholding the personal interests and fake egos, hardly taking into account the contempt, the hatred and the feeling of being scapegoats, the girls have to live with in for rest of their lives. The Vani girls have to surrender themselves like slaves enduring the pain, the agony and the punishment for sins they have never committed. 
The custom is mostly practiced in relatively under-developed areas and amongst illiterate segments of the society living under the influence of macho men, sardars and waderas hence should be dealt with iron-hands putting a firm stamp that the law firmly stands by the weak and fair sex, and more so they are human beings not the sacrificial animals who can be bartered to fend off the feuds.

Posted in "The Frontier Post"

http://www.thefrontierpost.com/article/186454/

Sunday, April 21, 2013

‘Only 53pc girls, 48pc boys in city aware of reproductive health rights’

Most parents and teachers are reluctant to discuss sensitive issues with children and inform them about the physical and emotional aspects of puberty, which pushes them to seek information from unreliable sources and exposes them to exploitation.
This finding was derived from a baseline study conducted by LifeLine, a non-governmental organisation.
Addressing a press conference in Jamshoro on Friday, Chief Executive LifeLine Omer Aftab said there was a severe lack of information in the 100 million-plus Pakistani youth. 
To date, no serious, concerted efforts have been made to sensitise them on their basic rights. Without proper guidance, youths adopt bad ways and are scarred for life. The LSBE course, which is a major initiative, is being taught mostly in urban and semi-urban areas and ignores 62 percent of the population.
The objective of the study was to “gauge and assess the level of understanding of different key stakeholders about adolescent and youth sexual and reproductive health right (SRHR) issues,” he said
Data was collected from nine districts of Pakistan — Islamabad, Lahore, Lodhran, Karachi, Jamshoro, Peshawar, Abbottabad, Quetta and Pishin. Adolescents, parents, teachers, politicians, prominent religious leaders, EDOs, district managers of population welfare departments and NGOs’ representatives of the select districts made the target respondents for the study.
Sixty-two percent of girls and 67 percent of boys in Islamabad have heard about their reproductive health rights, as compared to only 39 percent of girls and 50 percent of boys in Lahore, and 53 percent of girls and 48 percent of boys in Karachi.
Knowledge about contraceptive practices, sexually transmitted infections (STIs), emotional aspects of growing up and gender-based violence is low. These findings are also the part of the baseline study.
Lifeline also conducted a curriculum review and Learning Needs Assessment (LNA) of the Life Skill Based Education (LSBE) course taught in certain schools. The course imparts basic knowledge to adolescents to help them to cope with the physiological, psychological, political and social changes in their lives.
LifeLine’s review of this course says 84 percent of students between 12 and 15 years are in favour of the course being taught in schools. 
Furthermore, no objections were raised to teaching the LSBE course by any quarter, including religious leaders and politicians. 

http://images.thenews.com.pk/21-04-2013/ethenews/e-172564.htm