Monday, May 6, 2013

Trading a 13-year-old daughter for a new wife. Rangina, Afghanistan


Rangina’s mother died when she was 12. In 2003, at the age of 13 she was forcibly married in abadaal (exchange) marriage as her father wanted to acquire a new wife. According to Rangina, the man that she was forced to marry had mental health problems.
“I was my father’s only daughter, so when my mother died and he wanted a new wife he gave me away in exchange. The man he gave me to was mentally ill. I did not want to marry him, but I had no choice. My father did not listen, and my mother was dead. My father thought only about his new marriage, not about me, his daughter.”
Rangina says that her in-laws verbally and physically abused her:
“All the family members were beating me, and calling me names. I was so miserable. My husband couldn’t speak properly, so I didn’t understand what he was saying. My mother-in-law would always say to me, “You are worthless—see how little your father cared about you—he married you to my son, and he is like this, he is mentally ill.”
My father thought only about his new marriage, not about me, his daughter.
RANGINA
After one year, Rangina ran away. Despite coming from a remote and highly conservative area of eastern Afghanistan, she managed to journey to the capital, a perilous trip for a young woman to make alone. She made contact with the Ministry of Women’s Affairs, who arranged for her to stay in a shelter. Her husband’s family found out, and came to Kabul to demand her return. She told us,
“They came and asked for me to come back. I said no, they kept coming. I always say no. I don’t want to go back. I can’t go back. They want to kill me.”
An official who wishes to remain anonymous told Human Rights Watch that the family discovered the location of the shelter and made threats against her and her staff. The family enlisted the support of various powerful regional political figures to pressure the government to return Rangina to them. A delegation of elders from her province, with the backing of various senators and members of parliament, called on the Ministry of Women’s Affairs to return her. The Ministry of Interior also supported their efforts, despite the illegality of her marriage under Afghan law.
The case was even debated in parliament, where a majority of MPs who spoke did so in favor of Rangina being returned to her husband’s family. Some MPs also called for the Ministry of Women’s Affairs to be closed because it was encouraging girls to run away from home. The director of the shelter says that the debate became very personalized:
“In parliament they named me, they said I was hiding her, and that I wasn’t Muslim, I was Western, I was working for foreigners, for foreign ideas. They got 500 signatures against shelters, against me, against the Ministry of Women’s Affairs, and took it to the president.”
The lobbying attempts of the husband’s family culminated in a meeting that included representatives from the Office of the President, the Ministry of Interior, the Supreme Court, parliamentary representatives, and the Ministry of Women’s Affairs.
President Karzai became directly involved. Instead of ensuring protection for Rangina and enforcement of Afghanistan’s marriage law, he urged Rangina to trust her husband’s family when they promised they would not harm her. Rangina refused and said:
“I told Karzai that if he was so confident then he could send his wife or daughter to my village instead of me.”
The cousin of Rangina’s husband, Haji Munowar Khan, led the campaign to have her returned. He told a BBC reporter that Rangina would not be returned to her husband against her will, and she could instead be given to one of his brothers:
“We don’t want our woman to be in Kabul, we can’t allow her to have another husband. We’re not foreigners–we’re not Russians–we’re not unbelievers, we’re Muslims, and we are Pashtuns, and for Pashtuns three things matter–our religion, our women, and our country. To defend these three things we will give up our lives. We’ve promised we won’t do anything to her, and if she comes back to our village we’ll promise again, we won’t harm her at all.”
Rangina has now been living in a shelter for five years. Her attempts to gain a legal separation from her husband, which began in 2007, have so far been unsuccessful. Rangina’s husband has repeatedly failed to appear in court, which under the civil code can be grounds for granting a woman a separation. However, there has still been no resolution.
In August 2007, the Supreme Court accepted a request to have the case heard by the Family Court in Kabul on the grounds that her life could be endangered if she traveled to her home province. However, the Family Court demanded witnesses to prove that she suffered abuse and that her husband was mentally ill. Nobody from her home province agreed to testify on her behalf, because of fear of retribution from the husband’s family in the region. No witness protection program exists. Rangina said:
“I don’t like the courts or the judges. Whenever I go there they say, “Why did you run away? Why did you do this, why you do that?” And now they ask for evidence even though they know I cannot give it to them. It is too dangerous.”
According to a human rights worker connected to the case, the Family Court wants to delay a decision and wait for a presidential intervention:
“The judges are supportive, but they are too afraid to take responsibility because they have no security. There will be danger for the judge if she takes a decision.”
The head of the Family Court is Qazi Rahima Razayee. She denied that she is afraid to act. Instead, she said that the problem was that nobody wants to testify on Rangina’s behalf:
“Nobody wants to come to support her. They are saying that her husband is a good man, and he gave her clothes, food, medicine. They say she’s a bad lady to leave her home, she’s not a good lady.”
When asked why the court could not provide a separation on the grounds that the marriage had been illegal in the first place, since Rangina was underage and forced to marry, the judge said:
“She was 13 when she married this person. This was against our law. But if she didn’t want to marry her husband then she should have come to us at that time and made her objections. Instead she stayed with him for two years and she was happy with that, and only when she’s 15 does she come to us and complain, so then we can’t do anything.”
Faced with pressure from the president, hostility from powerful MPs, and extralegal arguments by the head of the Family Court, women and girls in situations such as Rangina have little reason to trust the state or government to protect them.

Child marriage and the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs)


Child marriage directly hinders the achievement of 6 of the 8 Millennium Development Goals. Simply put, the international community will not fulfil its commitments to reduce global poverty unless it tackles child marriage.
MDG 1: End poverty and hunger:
Girls who marry young do not receive the educational and economic opportunities that help lift them and their families out of poverty. 
MDG 2: Universal education:
Child brides are usually forced to drop out of school. The education gap between girls and boys in the developing world is often greater where child marriage is common. 
MDG 3: Gender equality:
Child brides rarely have any say in the decision to marry. 
MDG 4: Child health:
When a mother is under 18, her baby is 60 percent more likely to die in its first year of life than a baby born to a mother older than 19. 
MDG 5: Maternal health:
Girls under 15 are five times more likely to die in childbirth than women in their 20s. 
Child brides lack the information or the power to negotiate safe sexual practices with their often older and more sexually experienced husbands. 

Empowering Change for Adolescents around the World


Anju dreams of becoming a teacher or even a doctor, something that will give her a chance to make life better for her family and the people in her village. To do this, she will need to complete her education, delay marriage and pregnancy, and stay healthy. Most importantly, she will need the ability to decide whether and when to have children, and how many to have.
Discussing sexual and reproductive health for a girl as young as Anju may seem premature. Yet, each year, millions of girls in India and in more than 20 other developing countries whereEngenderHealth works are married too early--as young as 15--and begin having children.
What will happen to Anju's dreams if she has children before she is ready? What does the future hold for any teenage girl who has no say in contraceptive use, cannot protect herself against HIV or other sexually transmitted infections, and cannot stay healthy?
This is the life for many women and adolescent girls in India's poorest villages, where high-quality reproductive health care--or health care of any kind--can be a day's walk away. For example, in Jharkhand and Bihar, two states in Eastern India, 25% of teenage girls have already had a baby, and nearly half of those who are married want, but lack access to, contraception.
We are changing this reality. In places like India, doctors and nurses who are trained by EngenderHealth understand the special needs of adolescents, including how to counsel effectively so that they make informed decisions about contraception and nutrition. We also engage communities about the risks of early marriage and pregnancy, anemia, unprotected sex, and unsafe abortion, to help create a supportive environment in which adolescents can seek and access health care.
And we're seeing results. Last year, in Jharkhand and Bihar, we saw a steady increase in the number of adolescents who accessed health services.
We're hoping for similarly encouraging results in Texas, where we're piloting a program to reduce teenage pregnancy. This program, which is based on one that EngenderHealth has run in more than 15 developing countries, teaches teenage girls and boys to challenge harmful gender stereotypes that drive unhealthy behavior. The program encourages boys and girls to think and discuss issues together--like how to decide if and when to have sex, and to use contraceptives--using a mix of workshops, social media strategies, and youth-generated video messages. Hear what these young men and women have learned.
By seeking ways to protect and improve their own health, a 14-year-old girl in an Indian health clinic, teenage mothers in impoverished villages, and adolescents in Texas are on their way to improving their health and the health of others in their communities.
Access to health care and the ability for adolescents to make choices about their own sexual and reproductive health aren't limited to adolescents in India or even developing countries--this is a global health issue. In fact, more than 1 billion young people are entering their reproductive years, and they need high-quality sexual and reproductive health care to fulfill their potential and to thrive. Our responsibility is to work together to drive change and create opportunity for adolescents around the world.

Friday, May 3, 2013

Without serious political input girls' lives will not improve



Adolescence is an important time in life but for millions of girls in the poor countries, the onset of puberty begins a time of acute vulnerability
Anyone who has gone through the rigors of adolescence knows what an acutely important time it is in life. The experiences, relationships and decisions you make during your teenage years often fundamentally shape the course of your future history.
Yet for millions of girls across the world this is not only one of the most crucial, but one of the most dangerous times of their lives.
For millions in developing and middle-income countries, the onset of puberty begins a time of acute vulnerability. It is the time when they are most likely to drop out of school, to be married too young, experience dangerously early pregnancy, HIV, sexual exploitation, coercion and violence.
Approximately one-third of all girls in developing countries across the world are married before the age of 18. A 2012 United Nations Population Fund report concluded that girls who enter into marriage face serious health risks. Aside from being more exposed to violence and HIV infection, complications in pregnancy and childbirth are now the leading causes of death for girls aged 15-19 in low- and middle-income countries across the world.
Instead of being able to access the services they need to be able to make crucial decisions about their own sexual health and protect themselves, according the UNFPA report, girls are less likely than older women to be able to access sexual and reproductive health care including modern contraception and skilled assistance during pregnancy and childbirth.
The UN agency put this down to a lack of economic power, limited education and knowledge of sexual and reproductive health services and, crucially, many lack the ability to make independent decisions about their health.
"It's a simple fact that millions of girls across the world don't have control over their own bodies, their sexual lives and their reproduction," says Marianne Møllmann, senior policy adviser at Amnesty International.
Mollmann points to recent research carried out for the My Body, My Rights campaign, which exposes the catastrophic consequences of women and girls lacking access to effective health services.
"The problem is you don't need any more pieces of research to work out that it's a good idea to give girls control over their own bodies and that a girl's life chances will improve if they are valued and invested in. While this makes sense on paper, the challenge has been how to make this a reality on the ground."
The idea that investments in the reproductive health, education and employment of young girls could provide some of the most cost-effective and quick-win development gains and bring major long-term social and economic benefits has been gaining traction.
"A decade ago when you talked about improving girls' access to reproductive and sexual health services, this meant finding ways to persuade men and boys to let them use contraceptives," says Sara Seims, a visiting fellow at the London School of Economics and a senior advisor to the Packard Foundation in San Francisco.
"Now there is a recognition that this won't necessarily change anything unless you put value in the girls themselves, find ways to empower them and invest in their future."
In 2011 the World Bank attempted to put a monetary value on this idea of investing in girls.
The Bank explored the knock-on effect to national economies of reversing the trends in three widely prevalent aspects of adolescent girls' lives" – school dropouts, teenage pregnancy and joblessness. It calculated that Kenya could add $3.4bn to its gross income every year if all 1.6 million adolescent girls in Kenya completed secondary school and the 220,000 adolescent mothers were employed instead of falling pregnant early.
Yet while the evidence mounts, the connections aren't being made on the ground, says Kevin Watkins from the Brookings Institution.
"A girl's ability to stay in school is absolutely fundamental to improving her life chances, to give her the potential of economic independence, to avoid early marriage and decrease the chances of teenage pregnancy," he says. "Yet development work is often still done in silos. Reproductive health is seen as exclusively a health sector problem and vice versa with the issue of boosting numbers of girls in secondary schools being considered solely an education issue. Without taking a holistic view the reality of how to really improve girl's life chances isn't clear."
Without serious political investment in changing entrenched attitudes towards the value of adolescent young girls, nothing can really change.
"The problem with girls is that it isn't as simple as putting financial investment in education or health systems," says Watkins. "What we're dealing with is countries around the world with very stark gender disparity solidified in entrenched cultural attitudes at all levels of society, which still value girls only as wombs or dowries."
While some countries like Bangladesh have seen serious attempts at challenging those values, in many countries where adolescent girls are most at risk, enough is not being done.
"While we have seen a lot of high-level talk of the need to invest in young girls, you simply haven't seen political campaigns at either national or international level that seriously try to address this," says Watkins. "Until this happens as a political investment I'm afraid that these girls will continue to walk alone."

We must respect the decisions of young mothers

Young women who decide to have children are too often laughed at, disowned and denigrated by the wider community, a profound change in attitudes is needed


The sexual and reproductive health and rights (SRHR) movement has always struggled with young motherhood as an issue.
The principle behind our wider global agenda has always been about ensuring women, young and old, have access to contraceptive choices that will enable them to control their fertility and to choose when and whether to have children, which in turn will lead to personal, educational and economic empowerment. Yet when faced with those who chose to become mothers at a young age, we often find those very principles challenged and compromised – even within our own movement.
Generally, attitudes to young motherhood are affected by puritanical thinking regarding sex. That puritanical thinking might be the over-riding orthodoxy in a country or society, or it might be residual. If it's residual, even in societies that consider themselves to be liberal and enlightened in their acceptance of modern sexual mores, it still exercises a powerful influence.
When we think of young mothers in the developing world, we think of child brides and forced marriage. Here in the UK, by contrast, we are reminded of single young mothers struggling to make ends meet, unfairly regarded a burden to the public purse. While each might provoke a different policy response, both suffer the same underlying prejudice and stigma.
The basic puritanical dictum regarding sexual activity between unmarried females and males runs as follows: Young, female, unmarried and having sex: bad; Young, female, unmarried and pregnant: very bad; Young, female, unmarried, pregnant and having an abortion: very very bad; Young, female, unmarried and raising a child: Where do we even start?
Or, put more simply, for young unmarried women it's lose lose all the way. Damned if they have sex, damned if they have an abortion, damned if they decide to have and raise a child.
It seems that so many get worked up about the choices of others' when it comes to sex and relationships. We become self-righteous about their behaviour. We even stand ready to withdraw support when we would not withdraw such support from our own.
The unfairness of it is evident. After all, if the young woman in question is married then the points listed above all become acceptable, expected, and ordained as part of the natural order (bar item three – abortion).
This demonstrates wider society's clear confusion about the issue. But the SRHR sector is equally confused but for different reasons. SRHR organisations naturally support Comprehensive Sexual Education (CSE). We want young people to know about the basic biology of sex and about taking care, taking precautions, taking responsibility, avoiding infections, understanding options, and understanding emotions and the ways in which relationships work.
But what about a woman who actively wants a child when she is relatively young? She doesn't exactly fit within this construct. There are a few (very few) progressive CSE curricula which talk about motherhood and parenting, but most references to teenage motherhood in sex educationare firmly negative. And since there is a consensus that economic and educational opportunity can be limited by early pregnancy, well … we end up in a situation where it could be said that we're not teaching young women about teenage motherhood because we don't believe it's a good idea because we do see that it reduces a woman's future choices.
But individual choice, whatever that choice may be, is absolutely sovereign. It must be. It always is. In the same way that we argue a young woman should have the right to choose an abortion, we should also accept that a young woman who becomes pregnant at 16 and who knows that she wants that child, needs to be fully supported. The SRHR sector should be at the forefront of working out ways to do so, and it should be at the forefront of delivering the solutions required. Some of us are already doing that, but not enough as yet.
A young woman who chooses to have a child should not be laughed at, she should not be denigrated, and she should not be disowned by family, friends and the wider community. But there is every chance that – until attitudes profoundly change – she will be.
So there is a job of education to be done, which begins with her peers and with teaching and medical professionals, and then spreads among the general populace to finally erode centuries of accepted prejudice, intolerance and double-standards.
Hand in hand with education, we also need to provide support. Practical physical assistance which ensures that a young woman who chooses to be a mother is not cut off and cast adrift from all around her. That she has the help she needs, that she is able to meet with other mothers, to continue her education and gain the qualifications she requires or, if in employment, to return to work with the right support, which will be so essential to secure opportunities for her in her future years. And this is a global issue – not just one for the developing world. You will find girls and young women being denied choices and opportunities regardless of where they live.
And what about fathers? Why don't we teach young men about being paternal, and support them in learning about parenthood, and enable them to continue their education and develop their role as fathers? Because while this may shock many, there are thousands of young men out there who want to be fathers, who want to raise children, and who will make tremendous parents. Good/bad parenting isn't necessarily an age-related thing.
So if we believe in choice and in empowering young people in all areas of their lives, we can't exclude sexual and reproductive health and rights. As a movement, we must view any and all choices as legitimate and respected, regardless of whether we would make those same choices for ourselves.

Positive Action


When it comes to the fight against AIDS in Latin America, there is reason to be optimistic. According to UNAIDS, the epidemic is stable, infections are declining, and overall treatment coverage is high.
Thanks largely to wider spread availability of anti-retroviral therapy, the number of people dying from AIDS-related causes declined by 10 percent between 2005 and 2011, and approximately 1.4 million people are currently living with the disease.
“Pressure over the human rights of AIDS prevention, treatment and care has resulted in improved government policies and a better overall situation,” says Dr. Carmen Barroso, regional director at International Planned Parenthood Federation.

Thursday, May 2, 2013

Breaking the Cycle of Child Marriage in India



Savita Singh, a slight 18-year-old schoolgirl who confesses she is poor at math but aspires to attend college to study Hindi and history, admits she has another, secret dream.
"I want to work for the Haryana police force," Savita told me, explaining that she is passionate about prosecuting families who she says abuse and sometimes even set fire to their daughters-in-law in the region. "But I know that my dream won't be fulfilled. I'm not tall enough."
Savita shared her secret with me in a cramped, dark room two days before the horrific gang rape and subsequent death of a young woman in Delhi that caught the world's attention and sparked outrage across India in December. We sat on low charpoy beds, the wooden and rope structures that are ubiquitous in Haryana state, along with Savita's sisters, Kirin, who is 20, and Rekha, 15. High, concrete walls behind the girls were adorned with posters of Hindu gods and faraway places. Rekha and Kirin also told me about their ambitions to become teachers, to continue their studies, to wait to marry until they are ready.