Friday, May 3, 2013

We must respect the decisions of young mothers

Young women who decide to have children are too often laughed at, disowned and denigrated by the wider community, a profound change in attitudes is needed


The sexual and reproductive health and rights (SRHR) movement has always struggled with young motherhood as an issue.
The principle behind our wider global agenda has always been about ensuring women, young and old, have access to contraceptive choices that will enable them to control their fertility and to choose when and whether to have children, which in turn will lead to personal, educational and economic empowerment. Yet when faced with those who chose to become mothers at a young age, we often find those very principles challenged and compromised – even within our own movement.
Generally, attitudes to young motherhood are affected by puritanical thinking regarding sex. That puritanical thinking might be the over-riding orthodoxy in a country or society, or it might be residual. If it's residual, even in societies that consider themselves to be liberal and enlightened in their acceptance of modern sexual mores, it still exercises a powerful influence.
When we think of young mothers in the developing world, we think of child brides and forced marriage. Here in the UK, by contrast, we are reminded of single young mothers struggling to make ends meet, unfairly regarded a burden to the public purse. While each might provoke a different policy response, both suffer the same underlying prejudice and stigma.
The basic puritanical dictum regarding sexual activity between unmarried females and males runs as follows: Young, female, unmarried and having sex: bad; Young, female, unmarried and pregnant: very bad; Young, female, unmarried, pregnant and having an abortion: very very bad; Young, female, unmarried and raising a child: Where do we even start?
Or, put more simply, for young unmarried women it's lose lose all the way. Damned if they have sex, damned if they have an abortion, damned if they decide to have and raise a child.
It seems that so many get worked up about the choices of others' when it comes to sex and relationships. We become self-righteous about their behaviour. We even stand ready to withdraw support when we would not withdraw such support from our own.
The unfairness of it is evident. After all, if the young woman in question is married then the points listed above all become acceptable, expected, and ordained as part of the natural order (bar item three – abortion).
This demonstrates wider society's clear confusion about the issue. But the SRHR sector is equally confused but for different reasons. SRHR organisations naturally support Comprehensive Sexual Education (CSE). We want young people to know about the basic biology of sex and about taking care, taking precautions, taking responsibility, avoiding infections, understanding options, and understanding emotions and the ways in which relationships work.
But what about a woman who actively wants a child when she is relatively young? She doesn't exactly fit within this construct. There are a few (very few) progressive CSE curricula which talk about motherhood and parenting, but most references to teenage motherhood in sex educationare firmly negative. And since there is a consensus that economic and educational opportunity can be limited by early pregnancy, well … we end up in a situation where it could be said that we're not teaching young women about teenage motherhood because we don't believe it's a good idea because we do see that it reduces a woman's future choices.
But individual choice, whatever that choice may be, is absolutely sovereign. It must be. It always is. In the same way that we argue a young woman should have the right to choose an abortion, we should also accept that a young woman who becomes pregnant at 16 and who knows that she wants that child, needs to be fully supported. The SRHR sector should be at the forefront of working out ways to do so, and it should be at the forefront of delivering the solutions required. Some of us are already doing that, but not enough as yet.
A young woman who chooses to have a child should not be laughed at, she should not be denigrated, and she should not be disowned by family, friends and the wider community. But there is every chance that – until attitudes profoundly change – she will be.
So there is a job of education to be done, which begins with her peers and with teaching and medical professionals, and then spreads among the general populace to finally erode centuries of accepted prejudice, intolerance and double-standards.
Hand in hand with education, we also need to provide support. Practical physical assistance which ensures that a young woman who chooses to be a mother is not cut off and cast adrift from all around her. That she has the help she needs, that she is able to meet with other mothers, to continue her education and gain the qualifications she requires or, if in employment, to return to work with the right support, which will be so essential to secure opportunities for her in her future years. And this is a global issue – not just one for the developing world. You will find girls and young women being denied choices and opportunities regardless of where they live.
And what about fathers? Why don't we teach young men about being paternal, and support them in learning about parenthood, and enable them to continue their education and develop their role as fathers? Because while this may shock many, there are thousands of young men out there who want to be fathers, who want to raise children, and who will make tremendous parents. Good/bad parenting isn't necessarily an age-related thing.
So if we believe in choice and in empowering young people in all areas of their lives, we can't exclude sexual and reproductive health and rights. As a movement, we must view any and all choices as legitimate and respected, regardless of whether we would make those same choices for ourselves.

Positive Action


When it comes to the fight against AIDS in Latin America, there is reason to be optimistic. According to UNAIDS, the epidemic is stable, infections are declining, and overall treatment coverage is high.
Thanks largely to wider spread availability of anti-retroviral therapy, the number of people dying from AIDS-related causes declined by 10 percent between 2005 and 2011, and approximately 1.4 million people are currently living with the disease.
“Pressure over the human rights of AIDS prevention, treatment and care has resulted in improved government policies and a better overall situation,” says Dr. Carmen Barroso, regional director at International Planned Parenthood Federation.

Thursday, May 2, 2013

Breaking the Cycle of Child Marriage in India



Savita Singh, a slight 18-year-old schoolgirl who confesses she is poor at math but aspires to attend college to study Hindi and history, admits she has another, secret dream.
"I want to work for the Haryana police force," Savita told me, explaining that she is passionate about prosecuting families who she says abuse and sometimes even set fire to their daughters-in-law in the region. "But I know that my dream won't be fulfilled. I'm not tall enough."
Savita shared her secret with me in a cramped, dark room two days before the horrific gang rape and subsequent death of a young woman in Delhi that caught the world's attention and sparked outrage across India in December. We sat on low charpoy beds, the wooden and rope structures that are ubiquitous in Haryana state, along with Savita's sisters, Kirin, who is 20, and Rekha, 15. High, concrete walls behind the girls were adorned with posters of Hindu gods and faraway places. Rekha and Kirin also told me about their ambitions to become teachers, to continue their studies, to wait to marry until they are ready.

Tuesday, April 30, 2013

Mereso: The child bride who’s changing attitudes


Nine of the 10 countries with the world’s highest rates of child marriage are in Africa: Niger, Chad and Central African Republic, Guinea, Mozambique, Mali, Burkina Faso and South Sudan, and Malawi.
My country, Tanzania, did not make the list. But in traditional Maasai communities like mine, marrying off girls is very common.
I was married at 13 to a man in his 70s.
It happened during Christmas break. My father told my school that I had died. Even if he hadn’t, I would have been forced to leave when I got pregnant because that was the law at the time.
I gave birth to my first child within a year. I had no professional prenatal care and no trained medical assistance during delivery. I had to depend on my husband and his other wives for guidance. It was a very painful experience. Every time I became pregnant after that I felt sick and scared. Because of all these difficult births I have a hard time controlling my bladder and it can be painful to urinate.
Today, I am a mother of five at 29 years old.
In communities like mine, age is not understood as a number. Our traditional values dictate girls are meant for marriage, and when the men decide we are biologically ready, we are married.
Marriage is sometimes a way of forming and cementing relationships. But it is also a way of earning money.
My family received a bride price from my husband and then he took me away to become one of his wives. He beat me regularly, and so I fled back to my village. But my father and brother told me the price had been paid, this was no longer my home, I had to return.
It wasn’t until six years ago that I was able to take charge of my own destiny.
I ran away to the city of Arusha and met Rebecca, a volunteer with theYoung Women’s Christian Association (YWCA). Through counseling, workshops and friendship, I gained more confidence in my own voice and learned to support myself.
When I returned to my village, I found an ally: one of our community leaders, named Abraham. In his own extended family girls were running away from forced marriages. He felt obliged to support them by giving them shelter and food. Quietly, he was encouraging them to go to school hoping it would be a way to get girls out of their situation.
When he learned about how I was able to find support from YWCA he was inspired. Knowing there would be places for girls to go outside their communities helped convince him they would be OK if they left their marriages.
But I love my family and my community, and I didn’t want leaving to be the answer. So I set up a YWCA in my village and slowly, change is happening.
Some men and boys are not happy with what I’m doing. I have to be around others all the time to protect myself from harassment. I don’t know if my own father would approve if he were still alive.
But many are recognizing that this is the way forward — that girls have value beyond marriage. That we can earn money and contribute more to our communities when we stay in school.
My brother used to think I was wrong to leave my husband. But seeing how well I am doing selling traditional Maasai jewelry and clothing he is starting to respect my choice. He no longer beats me, but he still won’t let me have access to any of my father’s farms. Thankfully, I have supporters in my community who help give me other options to grow food for my children. I believe my relationship with my brother will get better with time. I am still working on it.
My mother is so proud. She used to fear my disobedience to my husband would reflect poorly on her and she would be cast out of the community. But now she sees I am welcome and respected and she is so happy to have me back in her life.
When attitudes begin to shift from within communities this way, then people start to have hope. And politicians gain more courage to act. Without support from community leaders, parliamentarians fear passing laws will cost them votes and they will lose power to make any difference at all.
Likewise, passing laws provides no guarantee girls will be protected unless they have community support: 158 countries have set the legal age for marriage at 18 years but the laws are simply ignored by communities where marrying children and adolescent girls is common practice.
In the fight against child marriage, the biggest battle is finding those who are ready for change and giving them the courage to speak to others.
Those of us who believe in the power of girls, who have seen what they can do when they have options, we need to tell everyone we can. We need to teach girls that it’s OK to say no to marrying before they are ready, and that there are places they can go if they have to run away.
We need to talk to families about different ways their girls can contribute to their livelihoods, so that marriage is not seen as the only option.
We need to show community leaders examples of girls who have stayed in school, learned skills, and have helped develop their local economies.
We need to convince politicians that they should pass laws to protect and empower girls, and that the people will support them if they do.
And we need to share our success stories with the world. Because people need to know we are fighting for change and they can join us in their own countries and communities.
Change is possible when we believe in each other. I am living proof.

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

How to curb child marriages in Pakistan


Eight-year-old Zahida was married to Dilshad, 17, by her father Abdul Rasool in exchange for Dilshad`s sister, whom the father wanted to marry. Can anybody call this a marriage? And one can only thank the media for pointing it out, before Abdul Rasool could marry Dilshad`s sister.
This is obviously not an isolated case, and child marriages amongst children — and girls being married to adults — are a regular feature in our society. This is happening in a state whose founder introduced the Child Marriage Restraint Act 1929 as a private members bill in the British Indian Legislative Assembly. He himself married an under-18, and thus perhaps knew the hazards of such marriages.
We must also give our colonial masters the credit for introducing certain laws to protect the female segment of the populace. Female infanticide was one such custom that was prevalent in certain parts of India, and which was banned.
Girls were put to death at birth by some parents because of the possible failure to find them a husband might bring disgrace to the father.
A related custom was to marry children at a very young age. This applied equally to Hindus and Muslims. The reasons were many, including domestic and sociological causes, like desiring to perpetuate the family name by marrying the son early; by marrying the daughter early to escape the discredit caused to the family by the presence of a grown-up maiden; or by the desire of the mother to marry her son early so that she may sooner obtain possession of a daughter-in-law in whom the mother could inculcate habits of obedience and who could share the domestic chores with her.
Some even married their young daughters to the Holy Qur`an, or an idol, sword, dagger, arrow or a tree so that they may not appear unmarried to conquerors or their Creator.
Statistics with regard to child marriage are mind-boggling. According to the 1901 census, for instance, 121,500 boys and 243,500 girls under the age of five years were married. Between the ages of five and 10 years the figures were 760,000 and 2,030,000 respectively.
There were no less than 1,277,000 widowed persons under 20 years of age in 1901, of whom 914,000 were females; of these, 6,000 widowers and 96,000 widows were less than five years of age; 37,000 widowers and 96,000 widows between five and 10 years of age and 113,000 widowers and 276,000 widows between 10 and 15 years of age.

Child marriage impedes girls’ empowerment and fulfillment of their fundamental rights




In 2011, the United Nations General Assembly agreed to designate October 11, every year, as the International Day of the Girl Child.  The day is being observed globally for the first time this year to create awareness of the situation of the girl child and ensure greater efforts are made to improve their lives. The theme this year is ‘my life, my right, end child marriage’. 



The launch of this joint statement reflects the United Nations commitment to prevent child marriage, which directly affects Pakistan’s ability to achieve six of the eight millennium development goals.

Speaking on the occasion, the UNICEF Representative in Pakistan, Dan Rohrmann, emphasised that early marriage violates the right to health, education, recreation, protection and other social and economic rights of girls and young women. 

Married at such a young age, my grandmother was destined to suffer many hardships. SAMJHANA from Nepal


My grandmother was a child bride. Her experiences are representative of the many Nepalese women who are victims of child marriage.
When my grandmother joined her new extended family, her days began as early as 3 o’clock in the morning. She was responsible for all of the grinding work (using a traditional tool known as a dhiki/jato). She was also responsible for fetching water, carrying heavy loads of cow and buffalo dung to fertilize the fields, cutting fodder, washing clothes and dishes, sweeping and mopping, cooking for the entire family, among other tasks.
Married at such a young age, my grandmother was destined to suffer many hardships. At the tender age of seven she was unreasonably busy with all the household and agricultural work. To go to school and study was unimaginable for her, although her husband could go to school even after their marriage.
When she was fourteen, my grandmother gave birth to her first child. The child died within a month. Her second child also died a few months after birth. After that she had several miscarriages, and between each pregnancy she was confined to the house and expected to do all the work mentioned earlier.
Today, my grandmother is 82 years old. She has five children (three sons and two daughters), as well as 14 grandchildren. Last year she underwent surgery for uterine prolapse, a condition from which she had suffered for two or three decades. Although she was suffering, she was unable to tell anyone, including her husband, because of lack of knowledge and confidence.